Is Missouri v. Biden Really a Victory for Free Speech?

(Background) In this photo illustration, social media and messaging apps are seen on a mobile phone screen on November 11, 2025. (Photo Illustration by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) / (R) Former US president Joe Biden speaks on March 6, 2026. (Photo by Kamil Krzaczynski / AFP via Getty Images)

Commentary by: Kenin M. Spivak
Monday, April 6, 2026

Free speech advocates are elated by the consent decree settling Missouri v. Biden. Proclaiming victory, the plaintiffs and First Amendment defenders lauded the outcome as an “historic” milestone (see here, here, and here).

Are they right to see it this way? At the risk of raining on the parade, I respectfully dissent from the conventional wisdom.

Missouri v. Biden (also known as Murthy v. Missouri) combined lawsuits filed by the attorneys general of Louisiana and Missouri with claims of several leading health care professionals. The compelling and mostly unrefuted evidence showed that the Biden administration had implemented a broad-based federal enterprise to coerce and collude with social media companies to suppress and de-platform criticism of the administration.

The plaintiffs sought to enjoin numerous federal agencies from taking any steps to demand, urge, pressure, or otherwise induce any social media platform to censor or restrict access to content.

 

The evidence showed that at least 80 senior Biden administration officials participated in a concerted effort involving at least 11 federal agencies and offices, including the White House, Department of Health and Human Services, Department of Homeland Security, Justice Department, State Department, Surgeon General, Census Bureau, FBI, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, and Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency.

Underscoring the left’s strange and newly formed view that the First Amendment somehow does not protect “misinformation,” “disinformation,” or “malinformation” (truthful information that nonetheless undermines the approved policy agenda), in 2021, CISA director Jen Easterly claimed that social media speech is a form of “infrastructure” that fell within her agency’s purview, and that Americans should not be allowed to make their own decisions about what is true.

Among many others, censorship targets included Donald Trump (suspended by numerous platforms; YouTube even suspended The Hill newspaper for posts that included clips of his speech at the CPAC conference), Sen. Ted Cruz, then-House Republican leader Kevin McCarthy, Donald Trump Jr., actor James Woods, radio hosts Sebastian Gorka and Dana Loesch, the New York Post, Washington Free Beacon, Federalist, and the satire site Babylon Bee.

 

On July 4, 2023, Independence Day, Federal District Court Judge Terry A. Doughty issued a preliminary injunction that blocked numerous federal agencies from communicating with social media companies for “the purpose of urging, encouraging, pressuring, or inducing in any manner the removal, deletion, suppression, or reduction of content containing protected free speech.”

Doughty found that there was a substantial likelihood the government had censored a breathtaking range of Americans’ communication, including: views on COVID unacceptable to the government; conservative-leaning speech; the Hunter Biden laptop story; discussions about election integrity and the security of voting by mail; parodies about criminal defendants; negative comments about the economy; posts critical of President Biden; and a range of other topics including gasoline prices, climate change, gender, and abortion.

The judge observed that the case “arguably involves the most massive attack against free speech in United States’ history,” adding, “the evidence produced thus far depicts an almost dystopian scenario. [T]he United States Government seems to have assumed a role similar to an Orwellian Ministry of Truth,” which altered historical records and disseminated propaganda to manipulate and control public perception.

 

Two months later, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously agreed that the plaintiffs would likely establish that the Biden administration had engaged in a broad attack on free speech in violation of the First Amendment. They replaced Doughty’s clunky 600-word preliminary injunction with a concise 83-word order that was in some respects stronger, but excluded the NIAID, CISA, and the State Department.

In 2024, the Supreme Court held that that the plaintiffs lacked standing to pursue a preliminary injunction. Adopting the progressives’ mien, the majority described the administration as a passive player in its censorship juggernaut, vacated the preliminary injunction, and remanded the case to lower courts to reach a decision on the merits, including the potential for a permanent injunction.

As the litigation proceeded, the 2024 presidential election pitted the Democrats’ support for censorship against the Republican platform, which stated: “We will ban the Federal Government from colluding with anyone to censor Lawful Speech, defund institutions engaged in censorship, and hold accountable all bureaucrats involved with illegal censoring. We will protect Free Speech online.”

 

On his first day of his second term in office, President Trump issued an executive order prohibiting any federal government officer, employee, or agent from unconstitutionally abridging free speech.

With the change of administrations, the table had been set for a decisive outcome. Both parties and the judge agreed on the gravity of the Free Speech Clause, and that, in the words of the consent decree’s preamble, the Biden administration had “trampled” those rights. The settlement could have embraced strong First Amendment protections.

Instead, the parties entered into a weak consent decree shrouded in powerful-sounding pap. The federal government agreed that for a period of 10 years, the Surgeon General, CDC, and CISA would not threaten Facebook, Instagram, X, LinkedIn, or YouTube “with some form of punishment (i.e., an adverse legal, regulatory, or economic government sanction)” for refusing to “remove, delete, suppress, or reduce, including through altering their algorithms, posted social-media content containing protected free speech” posted by the plaintiffs.

This anemic agreement does not limit other federal agencies, apply to other social media platforms, or protect anyone other than the plaintiffs. It lacks the breadth of Doughty’s or the Fifth Circuit’s injunctions, and provides an exception for the “Federal Government to investigate and prosecute criminal activity and threats to the United States’ national security.” The decree is so narrow that it offers no genuine protection even to the plaintiffs.

Perhaps the plaintiffs feared that their claims had become moot, or that the Supreme Court’s constricted view of standing or national injunctions would impede further litigation. Perhaps Republican state attorneys general wanted to get along with the administration.

Whatever the reasons, and while its recitals may be lauded, the decree’s effectiveness will be ephemeral. The First Amendment and Americans have lost an opportunity that may not recur for a strong permanent injunction that would have been nearly impossible to amend, modify, or avoid. Instead, we got press releases.

(Views expressed by guest commentators may not reflect the views of OAN or its affiliates.)


Kenin M. Spivak is founder and chairman of SMI Group LLC, an international consulting firm and investment bank. He is the author of fiction and non-fiction books and a frequent speaker and contributor to media, including RealClearPolitics, The American Mind, National Review, television, radio, and podcasts.

 

What do YOU think? Click here to jump to the comments!


Sponsored Content Below

 

Share this post!