N.Y.: Staten Island judge halts Mamdani’s second-home tax over ‘totally botched’ rollout

New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani speaks during a news conference to announce a lawsuit challenging the federal government's new public charge rule, which could make it harder for immigrants to obtain green cards if they rely on public benefits, at City Hall in New York City on September 14, 2026. (Photo by ANGELA WEISS / AFP via Getty Images)
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani speaks during a news conference on September 14, 2026. (Photo by ANGELA WEISS / AFP via Getty Images)

OAN Staff Lillian Mann
2:00 PM – Wednesday, September 30, 2026

A Staten Island judge has blocked New York City’s rollout of Democratic socialist New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s tax on second homes valued over $5 million, ruling that the Department of Finance (DOF) executed the process unfairly.

New York City’s pied-à-terre tax is an annual property tax on certain non-primary residential properties that took effect on July 1st under Mamdani and Governor Kathy Hochul (D-N.Y.) as an effort to “close the budget gap without reducing essential services or raising taxes and fees” on working New Yorkers, according to Sheppard.

On Tuesday, Supreme Court Judge Wayne Ozzi, a registered Democrat, wrote in a filing that Mamdani’s (D-N.Y.) DOF violated the due process rights of several NYC homeowners by using an unfair procedure to decide who owed the tax on second homes valued over $5 million.

According to the filing, the policy establishes an annual surcharge on non-primary residences, targeting one- to three-family homes valued above $5 million and individual condominium or cooperative units exceeding $1 million.

 

Randy Mastro, an attorney representing the plaintiffs, notably referred to the rollout as a “total screwup” in an interview with Spectrum News.

“Sometimes city administrations screw up. This one is a whopper. And that’s what the judge has now found,” Mastro declared. “The way the Mamdani administration rolled this out is not only a total screwup, totally botched, a debacle.”

Meanwhile, the city has already filed an appeal.  

 

“Monday’s decision is wrong, and we will invoke a stay of the injunction,” the city said in a statement. “With a stay, we will continue implementing the surcharge fairly, efficiently and in full compliance with the law, as we have since day one. New York is a city for the many – not a tax haven for the wealthy few.”

Mastro argued, however, that the city would be better served by correcting the process rather than filing an appeal.

“Do it over and do it right, issuing notices only to persons it has determined owe the tax,” Mastro said.

 

The central question following the filing is whether the city can complete the work before tax bills are sent out in November.

Mastro asserted that seven weeks is plenty of time, adding that meeting this deadline is essential if the city expects to collect its projected revenue this year. Meanwhile, separate legal challenges against the tax remain pending, according to ABC News.

Stay informed! Receive breaking news alerts directly to your inbox for free. Subscribe here. https://www.oann.com/alerts 

 

 

What do YOU think? Click here to jump to the comments!


Sponsored Content Below

 

Share this post!