
OAN Staff Brooke Mallory
1:20 PM – Tuesday, September 29, 2026
Former “American Idol” contestant and pastor Caleb Flynn was found guilty on Tuesday of aggravated murder in the February shooting death of his wife, Ashley Flynn, following a weeklong trial in Miami County.
Flynn, 40, was accused of killing Ashley, 37, on February 16, 2026, inside the couple’s home in Tipp City, Ohio.
Ashley, a schoolteacher and volleyball coach, was fatally shot twice in the head while she was in bed. Flynn called 911 at about 2:30 a.m. and reported that an “intruder” had entered the home and shot his wife.
Prosecutors argued that the reported home invasion was staged and that Flynn killed his wife as he sought to end their marriage and continue a nearly two-year affair with 24-year-old Alleigha Botner, a fellow worship leader at his church.
Investigators testified that they found no evidence consistent with an intruder entering the home, while prosecutors presented evidence they said indicated the crime scene had been deliberately manipulated to make the killing appear to be a burglary.
Botner, the mistress, was a central prosecution witness.
During the trial, jurors heard evidence from more than 100,000 text messages exchanged between Flynn and Botner, including messages in which Flynn expressed hostility toward Ashley and discussed the possibility of murdering her. Botner also testified about conversations in which Flynn discussed ways Ashley could be killed without him being caught.
Prosecutors additionally presented AI-generated songs that Flynn had created for Botner, triggering audible laughs in the courtroom.
The prosecution described the killing as part of Flynn’s efforts to begin a new life with Botner while maintaining his relationship with his two daughters and his position at his wife’s family business.
Those motivations were arguments presented by prosecutors rather than independently established facts about Flynn’s state of mind.
Flynn’s defense acknowledged his affair but argued that marital infidelity did not prove that he murdered his wife. Defense attorneys also emphasized the “lack of direct forensic evidence tying Flynn to the shooting,” including the fact that investigators never recovered the murder weapon.
Testimony showed that no blood from his wife was found on Flynn or his clothes, and police never performed gunshot-residue testing on him.
Flynn had pleaded not guilty to the charges, and two misdemeanor counts of intimidation of an attorney, victim, or witness were dismissed without prejudice before closing arguments on Tuesday. The jury subsequently returned guilty verdicts across the board, including on the aggravated murder charge.
He will be sentenced on October 5th.

Stay informed! Receive breaking news alerts directly to your inbox for free. Subscribe here. https://www.oann.com/alerts
What do YOU think? Click here to jump to the comments!
Sponsored Content Below
