Independent review finds public safety inconsistencies, but no ‘bad faith’ by UVU in Charlie Kirk’s assassination

An elevated view shows people gathering near tiered grass terraces and a concrete water feature within a campus courtyard at Utah Valley University on September 10, 2026 in Orem, Utah. Turning Point USA is hosting its "Freedom Built to Last" memorial service on campus today to mark the first anniversary of founder Charlie Kirk's death at the courtyard site. (Photo by Charles-McClintock Wilson/Getty Images)
An elevated view shows people gathering near tiered grass terraces and a concrete water feature within a campus courtyard at Utah Valley University on September 10, 2026, in Orem, Utah. (Photo by Charles-McClintock Wilson/Getty Images)

OAN Staff Katherine Mosack
10:46 AM – Saturday, September 26, 2026

An independent review commissioned by Utah Valley University (UVU) of the assassination of Turning Point USA (TPUSA) founder Charlie Kirk found that the university lacked a formal security plan for the heightened security needed for the high-profile event where the killing took place.

The 158-page report published on Friday did not find, however, any evidence that university employees acted in bad faith before or after Kirk’s brutal murder.

“It is the opinion of the Project Team, based on our review of all available information, that at no time during the events leading up to the assassination of Charlie Kirk, or in its aftermath, did any employee or agent of UVU act in bad faith or in willful and wanton disregard for the safety of others,” the review said. “With the benefit of hindsight, however, the Project Team identified several actions, omissions, circumstances, and institutional practices that warrant attention as UVU considers how to strengthen the safety and security of campus events in the future.”

The report followed and documented communication between UVU police and TPUSA, which began September 3, 2025, a week before Kirk’s death. It also included a timeline of events on the day of the attack.

 

The report summarized its conclusion within 10 key findings:

  1. UVU had a substantial foundation of safety policies and procedures, but implementation, role clarity and documentation were inconsistent before and during the events on September 10, 2025;
  2. The TPUSA event presented several factors — a high-profile speaker, anticipated protests, an open-air venue, elevated vantage points, significant public attention — that required a more formal written security action plan than what was in place on September 10, 2025;
  3. The open outdoor venue demanded more robust line-of-sight assessment, elevated position review, building access control, arrival and departure planning, crowd control, protest management and fixed-post assignments;
  4. The TPUSA event created a renewed need for standardization within incident command, emergency operations center (EOC) operations and emergency communications, which had existing issues identified prior to September 10, 2025;
  5. Security technology and situational awareness capabilities need to be more effectively integrated into real-time operations, given that technologies such as video surveillance were used as investigative resources instead of being used in the moment;
  6. UVU’s existing monitoring and information-sharing resources did not fully meet the need for focused investigations of specific threats or concerning behavior;
  7. UVU should formalize mutual aid arrangements with external agencies, which responded quickly and professionally on September 10, 2025;
  8. UVU should reevaluate its public safety functions in light of the increasingly complex risk environment surrounding major events, public speakers, protests, open spaces, etcetera;
  9. Recovery efforts after the shooting must be maintained, including more structured support for first responders;
  10. Utah is expanding public safety efforts including multi-agency collaboration and intelligence gathering, and UVU should engage in those efforts.

TPUSA raised concerns with UVU police about some elevated vantage points around Kirk’s location, some of which were recognized and responded to. On September 8, 2025, TPUSA’s security team mentioned the elevated Hall of Flags outdoor pedestrian walkway above the area where Kirk would speak, for example. UVU Police Chief Long sent officers to clear the area about an hour before Kirk arrived on campus the morning of the incident.

UVU pointed out that its security team did not have access to crowd estimates through the ticketing process, which was managed by TPUSA. Initially, UVU police staffing included only three officials: Chief Long, a patrol officer and a reserve officer. However, after noticing the crowd size, Long requested assistance from a uniformed UVU police detective, a sergeant and an officer.

 

TPUSA security reported 10-12 security personnel on the campus.

“Several key event-security decisions were deferred to TPUSA field representative even though UVU staff members raised concerns, including concerns related to holding the event in the outdoor Fountain Courtyard and use its own ticketing system rather than the University’s system,” the report read.

Reviewers also found that the university’s actions during the TPUSA event were “significantly inconsistent” with its normal policies.

 

The review was a collaborative effort between experts from Robert L. Davis LLC, Doherty Advisory LLC, The Lake Forest Group, and Brownstein Hyatt Farber Schreck, LLP. The team visited the sites, conducted more than 70 interviews and examined thousands of pages of university policies, training materials, operational records, digital evidence, and dispatch and communication records.

The report follows Kirk’s family filing a notice of claim alleging a “series of stunning failures and reckless decisions” by UVU that left Kirk vulnerable. Though this does not constitute a lawsuit, it signals the family’s intent to sue.

The family’s legal counsel, Brett Parkinson, released a statement as a response to the report.

 

“This report reaffirms the facts we laid out in our Notice of Claim: that UVU security was woefully understaffed and unprepared to manage the obvious risks associated with an event of this nature. UVU hosted this event, and in doing so, assumed responsibility for the safety of all in attendance, including Charlie. The buck stopped with UVU leadership and law enforcement. Justice for Charlie and his family requires true accountability for UVU’s fatal shortcomings that day,” the statement read.

Stay informed! Receive breaking news alerts directly to your inbox for free. Subscribe here. https://www.oann.com/alerts

 

What do YOU think? Click here to jump to the comments!


Sponsored Content Below

 

Share this post!